James Blish

English 3050 Online: Reading Guides

Titan

Shirt of Nessus
How Beautiful with Banners
Discussion Questions
1. Which elements of the setting are based on extrapolation from astronomical fact?

2. Is the bubble suit a convincing piece of extrapolation? Does it have a metaphoric function?

3. Imagine this story retold with a male protagonist. How would it change in imagery, tone, or meaning?

4. Ulla Hillstrom thinks through her dilemma in classic SF fashion, arriving at a desperate but inventive ploy to save herself. In very unclassic fashion, she fails. Why did the author end the story this way?

5. The psychologically symbolic elements in the story, such as the bubble, the flying cloak, the well, and the staring face of Saturn, are also explained rationally. Do the emotional and rational sides of the story always work together?

Contact David Lavery